Well, I'm wondering how the current server is staying alive w/o donations. I agree to donations that don't affect gameplay at all, like accesories, Hi5 is full of hats, eyeglasses, moving machines, transformations etc., there's always people willing to buy those
What's the point of a chronicle update? Hi5 is too much pew-pew, this server barely sees 200 daily-active people, half of them are old players who play here due to lack of competition; they enjoy boxing 7+ chars to farm empty areas.
Imo a new server with proper advertising would be a great deal, your no-donate policy is the strongest one available around and you can attract lots of new players with that.